Skip to main content

A Reply

After my post, about MLS 2 teams, I was asked a question.

@jas_bai on Twitter said:

“Good job covering why the MLS 2 teams aren’t a major problem, but you didn’t touch on a side like Wilmington taking on 7 NYCFC players for a one off game vs NYRB. 2 parts to this: they won and those 3 pts will be valuable IF they’re able to make a run at the playoffs. 2) what do supporters of Wilm…or any other non-MLS 2 teams feel when they have players dropped in? I don’t want Clt or Colorado to do it because I want to support my guys, not some players that will only be there once and never see again.”

The question is so multifaceted (and I’m so long winded) that my answer was too long to fit into 140 character incraments, so I’ve decided to write it here.

As far as points are concerned, USL rules allow for any number of loans to come at any time in the season for any length of time. Playoffs are the only time when stipulations apply. Any team with an MLS affiliate has the opportunity to use this rule to their advantage in any way they want. If utilizing loans ends up assisting the Hammerheads, or any other teams for that matter, make the playoffs, the team would not have broken any rules.

From a supporters perspective it’s a little more hazy. To be honest, I do find it odd to look at a roster and see unfamiliar names. I would prefer loans such as they were last year where players like Quillian Roberts, Daniel Lovitz, Jordan Hamilton, Mark-Anthony Kaye, and Manu Aparicio had long stints with the Hammerheads (I prefer this way because it allowed me to really get to know the ability of said players and build confidence in them. Now, when I see that a loaned player is on the roster, I find myself wondering if the loans are any good and hoping they won’t mess things up. So far, there haven’t been any disastrous loans, and the fact that the loans are signed with NYCFC speaks at least a little to their credibility as players.), but I don’t think those kinds of loans are necessary for the club right now. Last year, the Hammerheads had less players. Without loans, the Hammerheads only had goalie in the 2014 season, so loans at that time were a necessity to account for unexpected injuries and suspensions. This year, there is more squad depth. Since there are so many signed Hammerheads, I don’t see the need for long term loans. When the Hammerheads played NYRBII, the team had just played Richmond a few days before. That was a perfect time to utilize loans. The NYCFC players didn’t have to travel far their desired minutes, and most of the Hammerheads were able to rest for a game.

I don’t like to think of NYCFC loans and signed Hammerheads as “their players and our players.” I see it like this: NYCFC and WHFC have entered into a partnership for the mutual benefit of both teams. There are some NYCFC players who could use extra minutes from time to time, and the Hammerheads can provide it. NYCFC has invited a few Hammerheads (Corben Bone and Ashani Fairclogh to be exact) to train with their team. Both teams are abiding by the rules of their respective leagues, and both clubs are doing things that benefit each other. It’s up to each individual USL club to determine how they will interact with their MLS affiliate. If getting seven loans for the one day is what the WHFC organization wants to do, I’m fine with that. It resulted in a win for the club I support, and a win without red cards or rule breaking is perfectly okay with me.


--Marissa Blackman

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Please follow us on Twitter and like us on Facebook
We're always looking for more writers. If you'd like to be one, e-mail sidelineshindig@gmail.com

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

DIFERENÇAS ENTRE O FUTEBOL EUROPEU E O FUTEBOL BRASILEIRO

por Hugo Haacke Começando na Europa e se espalhando pelo mundo, hoje, o futebol é o esporte coletivo mais praticado em todo o mundo. Tendo objetivos e regras iguais, o futebol se diferencia de lugar para lugar na sua forma de jogar, torcer e gerenciar. Entre a Europa e a América Latina, onde o futebol é mais popular, há significantes diferenças, tendo como principal referência nesse continente, o Brasil, o país do futebol. A primeira diferença e mais perceptível é a tática e a forma de jogar. No futebol europeu, a velocidade durante a partida inteira é algo natural. Há também características gerais como o costume de manter a linha de quatro no meio de campo e, a estratégia de recomposição do time inteiro, o jogo mais centrado, objetivo e calculado. Já o futebol brasileiro, conforme o tempo passa, os técnicos vêm aproximando a tática de seus times ao futebol europeu – principalmente depois da copa de 1982. Mas em sua essência, o futebol brasileiro sempre se caracterizou por lance

Quem foi Arthur Friedenreich?

Por Hugo Haacke Afinal, quem foi Arthur Friedenreich? Muitos não o conhecem, mas Friedenreich,  apelidado carinhosamente como ‘El Tigre’, foi o primeiro craque do futebol brasileiro. Conhecidos por muitos,  até hoje, como uma lenda, Arthur Friedenreich conquistou muitos títulos,  e foi o pioneiro do futebol brasileiro sendo um jogador extremamente diferenciado com a bola nos pés. Filho de pai alemão e mãe brasileira, Arthur nasceu no dia 18 de Junho de 1892 na cidade de São Paulo. Pela mistura dos atributos físicos do pai e da mãe, Arthur era alto,  tinha olhos claros, era moreno e tinha cabelos encaracolados. Naquela época, os times de futebol não aceitavam jogadores negros,  mas, por causa de seu sobrenome, Arthur foi bem aceito nos clubes. Sendo paulistano, Arthur participou, em sua maioria, de clubes da cidade de São Paulo. Alguns clubes que ele participou foram: Germânia  (atual Pinheiros), Mackenzie, Ipiranga, Paulistano (clube no qual ele mais ganhou títulos). H

USL 2018 Roster Moves

by Marissa Blackman Last Updated on 3/16/18 at 6:34 PM EST This is a running tab of all the roster additions and subtractions for USL clubs. I will update this list periodically. An asterisk next to a player's name indicates that the player is on loan from another club. All updates are based on official announcements from each club. Atlanta United 2 AJ Cochran Diego Lopez Jack Metcalf Yosef Samuel Shawn Nicklaw Gaston Cardozo Brian Gambarte Nicolaus Caraux Kevin Barajas Paul Christensen Laurent Kissiedou Andrew Kendall-Moulin Bethlehem Steel FC Matthew Mahoney Chris Nanco Santi Moar James Chambers Brandon Aubrey Omar Holness Brandon Allen Olivier Mbaizo Aidan Apodaca AJ Paterson Prosper Chiluya Mika Catalano Drew Skundrich Charleston Battery Taylor Mueller Kotaro Higashi Quinton Griffith Skylar Thomas Tah Brain Anunga Joe Kuzminsky Jarad van Schaik Neveal Hackshaw Ataulla Guerra Ian Svantesson Nico Rittmeyer Jay Bolt Ryan Arambula O